Monday, May 4, 2009

Unconstrained Insanity

Obama on the type of judge he will select to succeed David Souter on the Supreme Court:
I will seek someone who understands that justice isn't about some abstract legal theory or footnote in a case book. It is also about how our laws affect the daily realities of people's lives.
Charles Krauthammer responded:
The idea that you ought to be thinking about how the law affects the reality of someone's life is something that you do when you are passing a law or create a law. That's what you do if you are a member of Congress who represents people and their needs.

But once the law is passed, the only job a judge has is to interpret the law without consideration of a person's standing in life. Otherwise you could never have, say, a bank foreclosing on a home, because who, after all, is more affected, a bank that might lose a few dollars, or a family that's going to lose its home and future livelihood, et cetera?

The whole idea blinds a justice and the statutes that we have outside our courthouses of a blindfold over justice is that you do not look at a person's station in life, their needs in life, requirements in life. It's entirely about the law.

And for Obama to state the exact opposite openly as a way that will guide him in his appointments is quite radical.
This is the epitome of an unconstrained vision. In video two Sowell talks specifically about Obama.

0 comments: